The U.S. nickel, while often overlooked, holds a surprising history and potential value. The original 5-cent coin in the U.S. wasn’t even a nickel; it was a “half-dime” made from silver that first appeared in 1794. The actual nickel, made from a mix of metals including, well, nickel, didn’t come along until 1866.
Many of the older and unique nickels could be worth thousands of dollars today, with collectors eager to find these hidden treasures in their loose change or coin jars.
The following list covers nine of the most valuable nickels still in circulation – you might even have one in your pocket without knowing it!
1. 1926-S Buffalo Nickel – Worth Up to $4,200
This rare Buffalo nickel, with the mintmark “S” (for San Francisco), was produced in 1926. Collectors prize it for its scarcity and unique design, and it can fetch up to $4,200 in pristine condition.
2. 1916 Double Die Buffalo Nickel – Worth Up to $3,800
A unique minting error made the 1916 Double Die, Buffalo Nickel, one of the most valuable. Due to a misalignment, parts of the design appear “doubled,” making this nickel worth as much as $3,800.
3. 1918/17-D Buffalo Nickel (Overdate) – Worth Up to $3,500
An overdate error, where one date is stamped over a previous year, makes the 1918/17-D Buffalo Nickel rare and desirable among collectors. This error can increase its value to $3,500.
15 Gold Coins So Rare, They Make Fort Knox Look Cheap!
4. 1879 Shield Nickel – Worth Up to $2,400
The Shield Nickel series, which ran from 1866 to 1883, includes the 1879 Shield Nickel. Its age and historical significance make it worth up to $2,400 if it’s in great condition.
5. 1937-D 3-Legged Buffalo Nickel – Worth Up to $2,000
One of the most famous error coins, the 1937-D Buffalo Nickel, is known for its missing leg on the buffalo design. The “3-Legged Buffalo” is a sought-after piece, and collectors are willing to pay around $2,000 for one.
6. 1880 Shield Nickel – Worth Up to $2,000
Another rare coin from the Shield Nickel series, the 1880 version is valued for its scarcity and age, making it worth up to $2,000 if found in top condition.
5 Rare Coins That Wealthy Collectors Obsess Over—Each Worth More Than $1,000!
7. 1942-P Jefferson Nickel – Worth Up to $800
During World War II, the U.S. needed nickel for military supplies, so some Jefferson nickels were made with silver instead. This change in materials makes the 1942-P nickel special, with a current value of around $800.
8. 1950-D Jefferson Nickel – Worth $600 to $800
Produced in limited quantities, the 1950-D Jefferson Nickel has become a collector’s item. In good condition, it’s valued between $600 and $800.
9. 1939 “Doubled Monticello” Nickel – Worth Up to $500
This error coin features a “doubled” design on the Monticello building, making it stand out. A 1939 Doubled Monticello nickel can sell for around $500 if it’s well-preserved.
Top 14 Vintage Coins That Could Make You Rich
How to Spot Valuable Nickels?
If you’re interested in hunting for valuable nickels, look closely at dates, mint marks, and any unusual features like doubled images or overdates. Coins in the best condition are generally worth the most, so check for coins with minimal scratches and wear.
You never know – a forgotten nickel in your change could turn out to be a hidden gem worth hundreds, if not thousands, of dollars!