Coins might not be as common in everyday life today, thanks to online shopping and contactless payments. However, those small coins you might have lying around could be worth a lot more than you think—especially nickels.
Certain nickels, once worth just five cents, are now highly sought after by collectors and can fetch impressive amounts of money. Whether you have a jar of old coins or just a few in your wallet, it’s worth taking a closer look. Here are 16 rare and valuable nickels that could turn your spare change into a small fortune.
Rare Nickels to Watch For:
1. 1927 S Buffalo Nickel
Many 1927 S Buffalo Nickels were poorly struck, making sharp, clear versions incredibly rare. If you have one in excellent condition, it could be worth up to $72,500.
2. 1913 Type 2 D Buffalo Nickel
This coin’s unique design makes it a collector’s favorite. Circulated versions are valued at $275, while pristine ones can reach $500.
3. 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel
Due to a minting error, the buffalo on this nickel appears to have only three legs. Depending on its condition, these coins range from $1,000 to $5,000.
4. 1913 Liberty Head ‘V’ Nickel
Only five of these nickels were minted, making them some of the rarest in existence. One sold for a staggering $4 million in 2018.
5. 1918 7-D Buffalo Nickel
This coin features an “8” stamped over a “7” in the date, a rare error that collectors love. Its value can go as high as $260,000 in top condition.
6. 1918 S Buffalo Nickel
Known for its poor production quality, this coin is still highly valuable due to its scarcity. It’s worth up to $35,000 if well-preserved.
6 Rare Coins Still Circulating That Could Make You Rich!
7. 1919 S Buffalo Nickel
An error-free version of this nickel is incredibly rare and can sell for as much as $65,000. Even circulated ones are worth around $1,000.
8. 1920 D Buffalo Nickel
Though millions were minted, few remain in good condition. High-quality versions are valued at $50,000.
9. 1939 Doubled Die Reverse Nickel
This coin’s unique double image on the Monticello building makes it a standout. It can sell for up to $7,800 at auction.
10. 1880 Shield Nickel
With only 16,000 minted, these coins are both rare and historic. They’re valued at around $10,000.
11. 1916 Double-Dyed Obverse Buffalo Nickel
This rare coin features a noticeable double die error on the date. Depending on its condition, it can fetch anywhere from $3,000 to $100,000.
3 Rare 1950s Coins That Could Be Worth Thousands!
12. 1926 S Buffalo Nickel
Limited production and time have made this coin a treasure for collectors. Its value can reach $135,000.
13. 1917 S Buffalo Nickel
Unique dye quality makes this coin a standout. Mint-condition versions can sell for up to $28,000.
14. 1867 Shield Nickel
Some 1867 Shield Nickels still feature rays in their design, adding to their rarity. These coins are worth up to $4,000.
15. 1950 D Jefferson Nickel
Despite being newer, this nickel is rare due to its limited mintage during a recession. Uncirculated versions range from $5 to $500.
Hidden Treasures: How Pennies Could Earn You $200,000?
16. 1942 P Jefferson Nickel
Known as “War Nickels,” these coins contain 35% silver. Circulated ones are worth $2-$3, while uncirculated versions can sell for $2,250.
Editorial Note: This article was created through automated technology, with all details verified and polished by our editorial expert.